Spent Grain Sourdough Bread

Making bread from spent grain sounds like a it should be a natural extension of our homebrewing activities. It feels like a waste every time I empty my mash tun into a garbage sack and put it out on the curb. The Internet is chalked full of frugal and innovative homebrewers transforming their grains into edible concoctions. Unfortunately, of all the recipes I’ve tried, and breads I’ve been fed by others, I’ve yet to have one that has truly impressed me.

Spent grain sourdough loaf.

The main complication with using spent grain (malted barley) for bread making is directly related to the grain’s inherent properties and acceptability for bread production. Bakers tend to use wheat because of its high gluten content and lack of husk. Barley doesn’t possess these same attributes, making it a poor grain for bread production. This is exasperated by the fact that once we’re done with the mash, we’re left with primarily fibrous husk matter, very low in protein and nearly devoid of any sort of carbohydrates. The only way to make truely artisinal quality spent grain bread is to realize this nature and take into account the ingredient’s limitations when formulating a recipe. Instead of seeing spent grain as a primary ingredient, I like to think of it as an adjunct, bringing a depth of flavor and interesting twist to my loaves of bread. The recipe described in this article will create a slightly sour, nutty, light and airy, spent grain loaf.

The Sourdough Stater – AKA My “Barm”

Once fed, your sourdough starter should double in size. On the left was taken right after the barm was fed, the right was taken 24 hours later.

Once fed, your sourdough starter should double in size. The left photograph was taken right after the barm was fed, the right 24 hours later.

At the heart of any sourdough bread is a living starter. Sourdough starters contain a community of yeast and bacteria which are used to leven and acidify the bread. While you can buy a commercial sourdough starter from places like King Arthur Flour, I started mine from scratch using techniques found in Peter Reinhart’s – The Bread Baker’s Apprentice. Beginning with Reinhart’s methodology, I then supplemented the naturally occurring microbes found on flour with the dregs from a number of sour beers. I’m not sure the magnitude of this addition in the grand scheme of things, but I’m pretty happy with how my starter acidifies and levens bread. This is aided by the fact that I like to keep my starter at a relatively low-level of hydration (62% flour, 38% water) to encourage extra acidification. Two days before I’m ready to start building my dough, I make sure to feed my starter and ensure that it healthy and able to double itself in size without too much effort. With each feeding, I double the size of my starter. Starter health is very important; if I’ve allowed the starter to go dormant in the fridge for an extended period, I will typically feed it at least a couple of times over a week or two before using it to produce bread.

Preparing the Spent Grain

I grind my spent grain in a food processor to avoid and large chunks of husk feeling rough in the final bread.

I grind my spent grain in a food processor to avoid any large chunks of husk in the final bread.

I like to store my spent grain dry so that it is shelf-stable and I can have it on-hand for whenever I want to bake a loaf of bread. To do this, I spread my wet, spent grain out on a baking sheet and dry it in the oven at the lowest temperature my oven can keep — around 200° F. I frequently turn the grain so that it dries evenly. The grain will take on a bit of color during the drying process, which helps add another level of flavor to the bread. Be careful not to burn the grain as it will lend an unpleasant flavor to your bread.

Building the Dough

When making my spent grain sourdough bread, I utilize a 3-day build and bake regiment. The recipe below will produce a 3lb. 9oz boule-type loaf that comfortably cooks inside my 6-quart cast iron Dutch oven. This amount of dough can be split up into smaller loaves, if desired. Cast iron baking was popularized by the New York Times’ article on ‘No-Knead’ baking and works well in my undersized, weak oven. Ratios of ingredients and the breakdown of loaves can be modified by maintaining the ratios while scaling down the amounts of ingredients.

Day 1: Build a Firm Starter

The first step is to create a firm starter. I like to make this very dry in order to encourage as much acid production as possible. The dough produced will be very firm and almost Playdough-like. The dough will get loosened up in the next step of the build.

The firm starter before (left) and after (right) fermentation.

The firm starter before (left) and after (right) fermentation.

8 oz. – Sourdough Starter (Barm)
8 oz. – Bread Flour
1.5 oz. – Cold Water

Mix ingredients in a bowl until well combined. Cover and ferment at room temperature for 24 hours. Dough will grow, but may not double in size during this period.

Day 2: Produce Final Dough and Retard Overnight

On Day 2, I build the final dough. The ingredients are mixed, the loaf shaped into a boule and placed into a 6-quart cast iron Dutch oven and then everything is placed in the fridge for a cold, extended fermentation. The dough produced should be slightly tacky and barely pull away from the sides of the mixing bowl. The amount of flour and water may need to be adjusted depending on your kitchen’s humidity in order to achieve this consistency.

17.5 oz. – Firm Starter Produced on Day 1
22 oz. – Bread Flour
18 oz. – Cold Water
1 oz. – Dry Spent Grain – pulverized in a food processor.
5 tsp. – Kosher Salt

1. Incorporate ingredients in a mixing bowl.
2. Knead in a mixer with a bread hook for 5 minutes.
3. Let the dough rest for 5 minutes.
4. Knead in a mixer with a bread hook for another 5 minutes.
5. Shape bread into a boule and then place in a oiled cast iron Dutch oven.
6. Place covered Dutch oven into fridge for approximately 24 hours.

The dough is shaped into a boule (left image) and placed into the fridge. After 24 hours, it has grown in size (right image).

The dough is shaped into a boule (left image) and then placed into the fridge for a long slow fermentation. After 24 hours, it has grown in size (right image).

Day 3: Proof and Bake

The dough is allowed to continue fermentation and proof at room temperature. The loaf is scored just before baking.

The dough is allowed to continue fermentation and proof at room temperature. The loaf is scored just before baking.

Four to six hours before baking the bread, pull the dough from the fridge. The dough may have slightly expanded in size, but will likely not have doubled. Allow the dough to continue its fermentation at room temperature until it has doubled in size. The time this takes will vary based on the make-up and health of your sourdough starter. Once doubled in size, place the covered Dutch oven into your oven preheated to 500° F. Bake bread covered for approximately 30 minutes and then uncovered for an additional 25 minutes. My stove is very unreliable and weak so your bake time will likely vary considerably. Allow the bread to completely cool before slicing and enjoying.

The bread has a fairly tight crumb which is great for sandwich bread or toast. Increasing the level of hydration in the dough will create a lighter crumb with larger holes.

The bread has a fairly tight crumb which is great for sandwich bread or toast. Increasing the level of hydration in the dough will create a lighter crumb with larger holes.

6 thoughts on “Spent Grain Sourdough Bread

  1. I’ve just started getting back into bread baking (I actually had stopped because when I moved into my new apartment, I no longer had an oven that could reach low enough temperatures to dry spent grain without burning it). I think you’ve got the right idea in grinding up the spent grain. I use the dried crushed grain which would sometimes be quit hard and unpleasant to bite down upon.

    Lately I have been using the long ferment/no-knead method, although I cold on a preheated stone and use higher hydration so I get a more airy crumb. I’m curious to get into sourdough; how long can you keep your starter dormant in the fridge and still successfully revive it?

  2. Thanks for the comment Dylan. I’ve definitely been inspired by the no-knead process; the biggest thing being my use of a cast-iron dutch oven to retain heat and steam. I feel like this has helped my bread achieve a much better spring than I was previously getting with my (pretty lame) oven. I am somewhat abusive to my sourdough starter and it seems to take it fairly well. I’ve kept it in the fridge up to month without feeding. When I go this long, I’ll usually do at least two feedings to get it back up to its previous vigor before taking a portion of it to build up my dough.

  3. Thanks for your well written instructions. I actually sun dried my spent grain (which actually had 10% acidulated malt to begin with for the beginnings of a fruit beer) and it has a strong sour aroma from it, particularly once ground. Do you think I can use it as an adjunct for making bread (particularly sour dough) or do you know of any possible uses for it? I’m just starting on my bread making venture and love the thought of spent grain use in my breads. Thanks.

    • I could definitely see how slowly drying the grains could cause them to go sour. If it is a clean sourness and nothing too funky (think rotten garbage, baby diaper, mold, etc.) then would could definitely use them in a bread. The percentage I use is quite low compared to other recipes I’ve seen, so a little bit of sourness could help the grains be a little more evident in the final bread.

  4. Followed the basic recipe, but I’ve been baking sourdough for years, so also used my basic recipe with the modifications in putting the bread together. Sourdough should go through an autolyse before adding salt, and the amount of salt is too much for the recipe – a tablespoon is enough. I also put the grains in when I put the dough together. After the autolyse, I add the salt, and fold the dough twice at 55 min. Intervals, and put it in the refrigerator for anywhere from 12 – 24 hours. The refrigeration time helps retard the yeast, continues the souring process, and deepens the flavor. Then, upon removing it from the refrigerator, I make my loaves, let them rise, and set the stove to 550 degrees. When it’s ready to go in, I score it, I put it on a stone (already heated in the oven), reduce the heat to 450 degrees, and put a couple of ice cubes into a small iron pan I keep in the oven for the purpose. About 20-25 min. Does it, depending on the style of loaf and size.

    • Hi Gary, thanks for the comments. This is quite a big batch of dough and the 5 tsp. works well for me. I should note that I am using kosher salt which is quite a bit less dense than typical ionized. This amount of kosher salt is in line with amounts given (by weight) from authors such as Peter Reinhart, and tastes right to my palate.

      I like to add the salt at the beginning as I don’t punch down my loaves for a second rise and am trying to keep as much of the bubble structure intact before baking. There isn’t really an opportunity to mix salt back in.

Leave a Reply to Gary Roth Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *